
Trade compliance is the work a company does to make sure its imports and exports meet the laws that govern them: customs law on the import side, export controls and sanctions on the export side, and the recordkeeping that proves both. In the United States an importer must classify, value and declare its goods “using reasonable care” (19 U.S.C. 1484), and an exporter must determine whether its item is controlled, whether a licence is needed and whether any party to the deal is restricted. A trade compliance program is the set of written procedures, responsibilities, training, records and checks that shows those obligations are met on every transaction.
Below are the obligations one by one, with their legal sources, followed by what a working program contains.
Trade compliance and customs compliance
The two terms overlap but are not the same. Customs compliance covers the import side: the declarations an importer makes to the customs authority (CBP in the US) about what the goods are, what they are worth, where they come from and whether they may enter. Trade compliance is the wider term. It adds export controls (the Export Administration Regulations and the ITAR in the US), economic sanctions, forced-labour import bans, and export reporting.
A company that only imports still has sanctions exposure, because a sanctioned supplier or a payment through a blocked bank is a problem whatever the direction of the goods. A company that only exports still deals with customs, at home and at the buyer’s border. So most programs cover both sides, with different people owning each.
Import obligations
The legal base for US import compliance is the Customs Modernization Act, Title VI of the North American Free Trade Agreement Implementation Act, which became law on 8 December 1993. CBP describes it as moving responsibility for classification and valuation onto the importer under two ideas, “informed compliance” and “shared responsibility”. CBP publishes guidance; the importer of record must use reasonable care to enter, classify and value its goods.
| Obligation | Main US legal source | What it asks of the importer |
|---|---|---|
| Classification | HTSUS and its General Rules of Interpretation; 19 U.S.C. 1484 | Declare the correct 10-digit HTSUS number for each article |
| Valuation | 19 U.S.C. 1401a | Declare the customs value, normally the transaction value with the statutory additions |
| Country of origin | 19 U.S.C. 1304 (marking); preference rules in the HTSUS general notes | Declare and mark origin correctly; claim a trade preference only when the goods qualify |
| Admissibility | Laws of CBP and partner agencies (FDA, EPA, CPSC, USDA and others); 19 U.S.C. 1307 | Meet other agencies’ requirements and keep goods made with forced labour out |
| Additional duties | HTSUS Chapter 99; antidumping and countervailing duty orders | Report and pay every additional duty that applies to the entry |
| Recordkeeping | 19 U.S.C. 1508 and 1509; 19 CFR Part 163 | Keep entry records for 5 years from the date of entry and produce them on demand |
| Bonding and payment | 19 CFR Part 113 | Post a bond and pay duties, taxes and fees on time |
Two items on that list need a word more.
Forced labour moved up the list after the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act (Public Law 117-78) took effect on 21 June 2022. It creates a rebuttable presumption that goods made wholly or partly in Xinjiang, or by entities on the UFLPA Entity List, are barred under 19 U.S.C. 1307. An importer whose goods are detained has to rebut that presumption with supply-chain evidence, which is a records problem as much as a legal one.
Recordkeeping sounds clerical, but it is what CBP examines in an audit or a penalty case. Under 19 CFR 163.4 entry records are kept for 5 years from the date of entry, and drawback records until the third anniversary of payment of the claim.
The money side of each entry (the duty rate, the fees and the bond) follows from these obligations. If you want the arithmetic, see how to calculate US import duty and how customs bonds are sized.
Export obligations
Export compliance in the US runs on a different set of laws and a different numbering system. The work happens in roughly this order.
- Decide jurisdiction: whether the item is a defense article on the US Munitions List (governed by the ITAR, 22 CFR Parts 120–130) or falls under the Export Administration Regulations (15 CFR Parts 730–774).
- Classify. Under the EAR, find the item’s Export Control Classification Number (ECCN) on the Commerce Control List, or confirm it is EAR99, the designation for items subject to the EAR that are not listed on the CCL.
- Check whether the ECCN’s reasons for control, the destination, the end user and the end use require a licence, or whether a licence exception applies.
- Screen every party to the transaction against the restricted-party lists: the BIS Entity List and Denied Persons List, OFAC’s Specially Designated Nationals list and others. The US government publishes a combined Consolidated Screening List for this.
- File Electronic Export Information (EEI) under 15 CFR Part 30 unless an exemption applies. The most used one is in 15 CFR 30.37(a): no filing where the goods under one Schedule B or HTSUS number, from one exporter to one consignee on one conveyance, are valued at $2,500 or less. Other rules can still require filing, for example when a licence is needed, so check Section 30.2 before relying on the exemption.
- Keep EAR records for 5 years from the latest of the export, any known reexport or transfer, or the end of the transaction (15 CFR 762.6).
Sanctions administered by Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (31 CFR Chapter V) cut across both import and export. They can prohibit a transaction outright, whatever the goods. For the export classification steps in more detail, see the ECCN, EAR and EAR99 guide for beginners and when an item is EAR99.
Why classification sits under almost every other obligation
I would argue that classification is the obligation the others depend on, which is why a weak classification process tends to show up as problems everywhere else. On the import side, the HTSUS number decides:
- the general and special duty rates
- whether a Chapter 99 additional duty applies, because those measures define their scope by HTSUS number
- which product-specific rule of origin applies under a free trade agreement, since those rules are written as changes in HS chapter, heading or subheading
- which partner-agency requirements are flagged at entry
- the statistics the government collects
Antidumping and countervailing duty orders are the main exception. Commerce’s orders state that the HTSUS subheadings are “provided for convenience and customs purposes” and that the written scope description is dispositive. A correct HTSUS number does not on its own tell you whether an AD/CVD order covers your goods.
On the export side, Schedule B numbers (the export counterpart of the HTSUS, built on the same six-digit HS) are used for EEI. The ECCN is a separate system. There is no reliable conversion from an HS code to an ECCN, because the CCL controls items by technical parameters (frequency, accuracy, encryption functions and so on), not by tariff heading. Two products in the same HS subheading can have different ECCNs, and one can need a licence while the other is EAR99. A company that classifies exports only for customs has done half the work.
The General Rules of Interpretation are the legal method for the HS side, and the ECCN side has its own order of review in the EAR. Both reward the same habit: get the full technical facts before choosing a number.
What a working program looks like
Regulators have published what they look for. The Bureau of Industry and Security lists eight elements of an effective export compliance program: management commitment, risk assessments, export authorization, recordkeeping, training, audits, handling of export violations and corrective actions, and building and maintaining the program. OFAC’s framework for sanctions compliance names five: management commitment, risk assessment, internal controls, testing and auditing, and training. CBP’s equivalent is the reasonable care standard, explained in its informed compliance publications.
Put together, a program that would stand up to a regulator’s review has these parts:
- A named owner with authority to stop a shipment, and management backing that is written down.
- A risk assessment that maps products, origins, destinations, customers and suppliers to the obligations above, so effort goes where exposure is highest.
- Written procedures for each obligation: how a product gets its HTSUS number, ECCN and origin; how value is built; how parties are screened; who signs off.
- Product master data under control, so the classification, origin and ECCN recorded for a part number are the ones that reach the entry and the export filing.
- Records kept for the required periods and retrievable by entry or shipment. A classification file that holds up in an audit is one example.
- Training matched to each role, with attendance recorded.
- Periodic audits that test a sample of entries and exports against the procedures.
- A route for errors: how a mistake is investigated, corrected and, where needed, disclosed. On the import side, a prior disclosure under 19 U.S.C. 1592(c)(4) made before or without knowledge of a formal investigation reduces the penalty for negligence or gross negligence to interest on the unpaid duties, provided the duties are tendered.
None of these elements needs to be large. A company with five import entries a month can have a two-page procedure and a spreadsheet of classifications with reasons. What regulators look for is that the steps exist, are followed and leave evidence.
What happens when it fails
On the import side, 19 U.S.C. 1592 penalises material false statements or omissions made through fraud, gross negligence or negligence, even where no duty was lost. The maximum civil penalties are:
| Culpability | Maximum penalty where duty was lost | Where no duty was lost |
|---|---|---|
| Negligence | Lesser of domestic value or 2 times the lost duties, taxes and fees | 20% of dutiable value |
| Gross negligence | Lesser of domestic value or 4 times the lost duties, taxes and fees | 40% of dutiable value |
| Fraud | Domestic value of the merchandise | Domestic value |
Clerical errors and mistakes of fact are not violations unless they form a pattern of negligent conduct. Export control and sanctions violations carry their own civil and criminal penalties under separate statutes, with civil maximums adjusted for inflation; check the current figures in the relevant regulations before quoting them.
The mistakes that lead there are usually ordinary ones. The ten common trade compliance mistakes are mostly process gaps: no owner, no records, codes copied from a supplier’s invoice.
Questions people ask
What does a trade compliance specialist do day to day?
Most of the work is research and review: classifying new products, checking entries and export filings before or after they are made, answering questions from purchasing and sales about duty or licensing, screening customers, keeping procedures and records current, and reading regulatory changes to see which products they touch. Larger companies split the role into import, export and sanctions specialists. If you are considering the field, see what an international trade specialist does.
Can a customs broker or freight forwarder do our trade compliance for us?
A licensed customs broker files entries and must advise its client of errors it knows about, but in the US the importer of record still carries the reasonable care obligation for classification and value. A forwarder arranges transport. Either can do part of the work under your instructions; neither takes over your legal responsibility.
Is trade compliance only for large companies?
No. The obligations attach to every entry and every export, whatever the company’s size. A small importer has fewer transactions to control, so the program is smaller, but the legal standard is the same.
If you need help setting up the classification part of a compliance program, or training staff on it, Surajit works on these questions and can be reached through the contact page.
Sources
- 19 U.S.C. 1484, entry of merchandise (Cornell LII)
- 19 U.S.C. 1592, penalties for fraud, gross negligence and negligence (Cornell LII)
- 19 CFR 163.4, record retention period (eCFR)
- CBP, What Every Member of the Trade Community Should Know About: Tariff Classification (Informed Compliance Publication)
- CBP, Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act
- 15 CFR 30.37, EEI filing exemptions (eCFR)
- 15 CFR 762.6, EAR record retention (eCFR)
- Federal Register, 75 FR 22369 (28 April 2010), example of AD order scope language on HTSUS subheadings
- 15 CFR 734.3, items subject to the EAR and EAR99 (eCFR)
- BIS, Export compliance programs and the eight elements
- OFAC, A Framework for OFAC Compliance Commitments
This article explains the law and practice in general terms. It is not legal advice on a specific product or shipment; for that, check the current official sources or ask a qualified adviser.